Ruth Eller

Ruth EllerRuth EllerRuth Eller

Ruth Eller

Ruth EllerRuth EllerRuth Eller
  • Home
  • Let's Get Acquainted
  • Communication
    • Let's Stay in Touch
    • Grading FYI
    • Volunteering
    • News to Use
    • Class Schedule
  • Be Prepared
  • CURRICULUM
    • The Listening Post
    • Math Facts Practice
    • Under the Ocean Thinking
    • Reading Log - Top 4
    • Word Power
    • Spelling
    • Geology
    • Writing Information Essay
    • Test Support
  • Problem Solving
  • Growth Mindset
    • How to Praise
    • How NOT to Praise
    • Growth Mindset Videos
  • Recommended Books
  • More
    • Home
    • Let's Get Acquainted
    • Communication
      • Let's Stay in Touch
      • Grading FYI
      • Volunteering
      • News to Use
      • Class Schedule
    • Be Prepared
    • CURRICULUM
      • The Listening Post
      • Math Facts Practice
      • Under the Ocean Thinking
      • Reading Log - Top 4
      • Word Power
      • Spelling
      • Geology
      • Writing Information Essay
      • Test Support
    • Problem Solving
    • Growth Mindset
      • How to Praise
      • How NOT to Praise
      • Growth Mindset Videos
    • Recommended Books

  • Home
  • Let's Get Acquainted
  • Communication
    • Let's Stay in Touch
    • Grading FYI
    • Volunteering
    • News to Use
    • Class Schedule
  • Be Prepared
  • CURRICULUM
    • The Listening Post
    • Math Facts Practice
    • Under the Ocean Thinking
    • Reading Log - Top 4
    • Word Power
    • Spelling
    • Geology
    • Writing Information Essay
    • Test Support
  • Problem Solving
  • Growth Mindset
    • How to Praise
    • How NOT to Praise
    • Growth Mindset Videos
  • Recommended Books

reading log version a

tips for writing a good post-it

write about something important

As we've talked about, good readers are doing a LOT of thinking when they are reading!  BUT, now it's time to focus on your thoughts that are about something important. You have a help sheet in your reading binder that helps you figure out if something is important.

Stuff like:

  • Is it just interesting? If it disappeared from the book, would it crash the story?
  • Is it something worth talking about? Maybe we might even have different and strong opinions about it?
  • Is it a "game changer?"
  • Does it show how a main character is changing?

write enough

You might have a great idea.  For example, when you read about Captain Orlov arriving on the island, you might have thought that he was a jerk. You were so right!  However, if you just wrote "Captain Orlov is a jerk!" you started with a great idea. But, you have to write more to really show your deep thinking.  Instead, add more like this:

  • Captain Orlov is a jerk! He stand with his fist on his hips like the island belonged to him. Then he starts shouting! I would not trust him.
  • Captain Orlov is a jerk!  He doesn't want to pay the tribe fairly. He actually starts arguing and says why does he even have to pay? 
  • Captain Orlov is a jerk!  He says the tribe doesn't own the ocean so he shouldn't have to pay anything. But he suddenly agrees to pay. Weird!

you are inferring something that really matters

The author doesn't always come right out and explain everything to the reader. So we learn how to use clues to figure something out. You might actually have an "aha" moment!

For example:

  • When the tribe wouldn't share their fish, I'm pretty sure that the Aleuts will do something really bad to punish the tribe. Maybe they'll steal the fish?
  • When Chief Chowig quietly works on his spear when he thinks the Aluets are leaving without paying, I think he is angry. He is probably thinking that he will not just let them leave. And he's getting ready to stop that.

feelings matter

As you read, are you feeling something? Like you want to jump in and warn the character not to do something? Are you overwhelmed with worry? Do you rejoice when something good happens? These are important things to write about. However, don't just say your feeling. You need to say why it matters.

For example:

  • Karana's father is dead!  She must feel devastated! And now her life will change forever without any parents to take care of her. I would cry so much because I love my parents. So I think she would too.
  • When Karana gets on the ship she sees Ramo on the shore. She is overwhelmed to think of him all alone. She's the big sister! She loves him so much she actually jumps off the ship to join him. Wow!

if you have a question, you have to answer it

We've talked about how readers have lots of questions when they read. It's okay to write a question on a post-it. BUT it needs to be about something important. Also, you MUST answer it in a meaningful way.

For example:

  • BAD EXAMPLE:  Why did Karana try to get to the mainland in a canoe? 
  • GOOD EXAMPLE: Why did Karana try to get to the mainland in a canoe? It was so dangerous she could even die! I think she's so lonely and sad she'll take any risk to find her tribe.

we are learning about what good readers do

good readers visualize

When you read a fictional book, do you imagine what is happening in your head? Good readers almost feel like they are watching a movie. They can imagine what the characters look like and basically "see" the action that is happening.

good readers use their schema

We all have experienced a lot in our real life. For example, you might have played basketball, gone to a birthday party, or felt sad if a good friend moved far away. These experiences are call schema.

All of your real life experiences actually help you understand what the characters in the book are feeling.  For example, if the book character is feeling lonely, you can understand because you might have felt lonely before too.  Or if the book character is worried about playing in a basketball tournament, you can understand if you also had a similar experience.


All of our schema helps us to really relate to what the book character is going through. It helps the action feel more real.

good readers get "into" the story

So...if you are visualizing and using your schema to understand what characters are feeling, you actually can get so absorbed into a book that you feel like you "jump into the book."

You can tell that this is happening if, when you read, you almost forget the real world. Maybe your mom calls you to dinner and you don't even hear her voice! LOL!

character's feelings

The bottom line is, you start to feel like the characters in the book are REAL people!  That means you react to what is happening to them like they are friends or people you care about.

You can tell this is happening when you feel excited when they are excited. You feel relieved when they escape danger.  You gasp when something terrible happens. You cry when they experience something sad like if their pet died.


good readers infer

What does infer mean?  It means you use clues to figure out something. Authors don't always tell you everything. 

For example, the author might write:

Suzie Q skipped down the stairs, jumping the last two. She scurried into the kitchen and grabbed her lunch and gave her mom a hug. Then she raced out the door, heading to school for her first day of fourth grade.

You probably figured out:

Suzie Q is excited that the first day of school has arrived. She is probably feeling confident.

The author COULD have just said she felt excited and confident about the first day of school. But, that is the boring way to do it.  

Good readers can use the clues to figure it all out without the author telling you everything.

good readers experience metacognition

I know this sounds weird. Metacognition might be a word you have never even heard about.  It basically means to be aware of what you are thinking. So, the bottom line is that good readers are thinking about their thinking! Does that make sense?

For example, while you read, you realize something isn't making sense. Or while you read, you notice how you are reacting to what is happening. Or while you read, you understand that you were inferring to figure out what the character was feeling.  Or while you read, you realize that you are forming a strong opinion about what the character decided to do.

good readers determine importance

Think of your favorite book.   There are probably lots of reasons why you love it. Maybe it's funny. Maybe you really relate to the characters. Maybe the author is really good at building suspense.  

All of that is awesome. BUT, there is a big difference between thinking something is funny or interesting and realizing that something super important just happened in the story.

For example, a character might be having fun at a birthday party and someone throws a water balloon at his head. That is hilarious! You might have even experienced that yourself! But, that doesn't mean it is important.

Ask yourself, "If that scene got left out of the book, does it change the plot?" Or another way to think about it if that scene disappeared does it actually crash the story?  

So, in our example, what if during the birthday party the character's best friend broke up with him.  Now THAT could end up changing the story completely. So that counts as something important.

HOW WE SHOW OUR THINKING AND THE WEEKLY ROUTINE

WE WILL BE READING TOGETHER

This is the beginning of the year. As such, we will be doing most of the reading and even the assignments at school.

At first, I will be modeling how we write down our thinking.

Then, the students will practice doing this on their own or as partners.

They will get lots of feedback from me of course.

The thinking will get written down in 2 main ways:


  • Writing on post-its
  • Writing on a Reading Log (Version A). These are kept in the Reading Binder that was provided the first day of school.

island of the blue dolphins

We will ALL be reading Island of the Blue Dolphins together in class. This is very important so that all my modeling and examples will make sense to everyone since we are reading the same book. 

They will all have their own book of Island of the Blue Dolphins. Most work will be done in class while we are reading this book. However, if they need to finish something, they will take home the book along with their Reading Binder so they can complete the work. 

reading log version A

We will write ideas we were thinking about as we were reading each day in our Reading Log Version A.  

We will write BRIEF notes about all those ways good readers process as they read that were explained above.

The students should pick 3 or 4 areas to write a comment on. They don't need to fill out every line.

An example of a filled out log is posted below.


fyi: the reading log is graded

Each week the students will fill out the reading log.

They will show it to me at the end of the week (usually Friday).

They will receive a grade and then I am asking parents to sign the log next to the grade in order to keep informed about how your child is doing.

Feel free to contact me with questions of course!

The signed reading log needs to be shown to me each Monday.

Thank you!


example of a reading log filled out

Download PDF

we also show our thinking with post-its

think while you read

This is related to something good readers do that we call metacognition. We talked about this above.

Even if you are doing great thinking while you read, you need to be aware of it. And you need to make sure you "capture" your ideas so you don't forget them.

So, how do we do that?  We write it on post-its and stick them in the book exactly where you had the idea!

For each chapter you should have at least 2 good ideas to capture.

You will write your ideas on post-its. Those are small, right? So don't panic...it's not like you will be writing a lot!

And don't forget, we will do a lot of this together and I will be showing you how to do it. Then you will start doing it on your own.

Look below for tips on how to write good post-its.

Ruth Ellerhttps://websites.godaddy.com/science

Copyright © 2025 Ruth Eller - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

DeclineAccept